Protection & Deliverance

Susan E. J. Martineau's Miraculous Preservation from an Indian Abduction

Published October 18, 2026 at 1:07 PM

Contributed by

Young Woman's Journal Research

Share:XFacebookEmail

In 1850, during the journey across the plains, an Indian Cheyenne demanded the then fourteen-year-old Susan E. J. Martineau as his wife after a young man in the company jokingly suggested she could be sold for five horses and other items. The Indian returned the next morning to collect his 'bride' and, upon being denied, threatened revenge. While the company was camped near the Platte River during a violent storm, Susan was holding a tent pole when she was suddenly lifted onto a horse by unseen hands. A flash of lightning revealed the Cheyenne attempting to carry her off, at which point she screamed and jumped to the ground, and the men in the camp rushed to her aid, forcing the Indian to flee.

The young man who initiated the jest was identified as a deserting soldier from Fort Kearney. Martineau notes that the Cheyenne man was approximately twenty years of age and that the incident occurred while the company was traveling to Salt Lake City, where they arrived in October 1850. The tent incident took place a few days after the Indian had threatened the company in a furious rage, causing significant concern as the Indians had stopped traveling alongside the camp and were no longer visible.

In Their Own Words

“In the summer of 1850 the writer, then just fourteen, crossed the plains with a company of Latter-day Saints, led by Capt. Stephen Markham, arriving in Salt Lake City in October. While traveling up the Platte a large party of Cheyennes journeyed in the same direction, usually camping not more than a mile or so distant from us, and often visited our camp to trade or for amusement. One evening a young Cheyenne, probably twenty years of age, who had been a frequent visitor, announced that he desired the writer for his wife, and would pay a good price for her. "All right!" said a young man who had recently joined our company—a deserting soldier from Fort Kearney—"All right! You may have her for five horses, five buffalo robes, and some dried meat, and two antelope skins." This the young man said by way of a joke, little thinking the Indian took it in earnest, or realizing the consequences which might follow. The Indian assented, saying he would come " one sleep " and bring the pay. Many were the mock congratulations showered upon the bride-to-be and requests for invitations to the wedding, much to the annoyance of the prospective bride. But the next morning affairs assumed a serious aspect. The Cheyenne appeared early in the morning with the horses and other articles specified, and demanded his bride. He was told that it was all in fun—a joke—and that the Mormons did not sell their girls either to white men or Indians. Also, that the young man who had made the bargain was no relative of the girl, and had no authority over her. But all this was words thrown away. The Indian was determined to have his bride. A few days after the dispute our company camped on the bank of the Platte, about fifteen or twenty feet above the narrow river bottom, which was covered with a dense growth of willows. At sunset a terrible tempest of rain, hurricane, thunder and lightning came upon us, blowing wagon covers loose, leveling tents and drenching bedding and clothing. As our tent was about to fall the writer rushed out to hold up the rear tent pole while others held the other one up and drove the tent pegs more firmly into the sodden soil. The darkness, like that of Egypt, was illumined at intervals by blinding lightning flashes, and rain fell as in a deluge. While thus holding up the tent pole with all her strength, she suddenly felt herself lifted upon a horse by unseen hands, and some one sprang upon the horse behind her. At this instant a blinding flash of lightning revealed the young Cheyenne. With a scream the writer sprang to the ground, and men rushed to her assistance; and the Indian, foiled of his prey, dashed down among the willows and was gone in an instant. In the storm and darkness pursuit was impossible, and that was the last we ever saw of him or his party.”

— Susan E. J. Martineau, 'Almost an Indian Bride,' Young Woman's Journal, June 1907

Sources & References

The Young Woman's Journal, vol. 18 no. 6 (June 1907). L. Tom Perry Special Collections, Harold B. Lee Library, Brigham Young University digital collections. https://contentdm.lib.byu.edu/digital/collection/YWJ/id/15254 (account extracted verbatim from the collection's page-level OCR; research confidence: high) Additional sources (periodical research): Susan E. J. Martineau, 'Almost an Indian Bride,' Young Woman's Journal, vol. 18, no. 6 (June 1907), 264-265. https://history.churchofjesuschrist.org/chd/transcript?name=transcript-for-susan-e-j-martineau-almost-an-indian-bride-young-womans-journal Full first-person account: Susan E. J. Martineau, 'Almost an Indian Bride,' Young Woman's Journal, vol. 18, no. 6 (June 1907), 264-265. https://history.churchofjesuschrist.org/chd/transcript?lang=eng&name=transcript-for-susan-e-j-martineau-almost-an-indian-bride-young-womans-journal

Miracle of the Week

One remarkable, documented account in your inbox every Monday, drawn from the full archive.