Acts of God / Intervention

Joseph Smith — The Campbellite Preacher Who Asked for a Notable Miracle (c. 1835)

Published September 28, 2026 at 7:50 AM

1830s
Not specified
Share:XFacebookEmail

A Campbellite preacher named Hayden came to Joseph Smith claiming he would support the Church if he were shown a 'notable miracle'. When Joseph Smith offered to paralyze him, make him blind, dumb, or wither a hand, the preacher refused the offer, demonstrating that he did not actually want a miracle.

In Their Own Words

“I recollect a Campbellite preacher who came to Joseph Smith, I think his name was Hayden. He came in and made himself known to Joseph, and said that he had come a considerable distance to be convinced of the truth. "Why," said he, "Mr. Smith, I want to know the truth, and when I am convinced, I will spend all my talents and time in defending and spreading the doctrines of your religion, and I will give you to understand that to convince me is equivalent to convincing all my society, amounting to several hundreds." Well, Joseph commenced laying before him the coming forth of the work, and the first principles of the Gospel, when Mr. Hayden exclaimed, "O this is not the evidence I want, the evidence that I wish to have is a notable miracle; I want to see some powerful manifestation of the power of God, I want to see a notable miracle performed; and if you perform such a one, then I will believe with all my heart and soul, and will exert all my power and all my extensive influence to convince others; and if you will not perform a miracle of this kind, then I am your worst and bitterest enemy." "Well," said Joseph, "what will you have done? Will you be struck blind, or dumb? Will you be paralyzed, or will you have one hand withered? Take your choice, choose which you please, and in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ it shall be done." "That is not the kind of miracle I want," said the preacher. "Then, sir," replied Joseph, "I can perform none, I am not going to bring any trouble upon anybody else, sir, to convince you." — George A. Smith, Journal of Discourses 2:323-334”

Sources & References

Journal of Discourses, Volume 2 (pages 323-334), discourse 49. https://journalofdiscourses.com/2/49 (extracted verbatim from source text; research confidence: high)

Every published account is vetted against its sources — read our editorial standards.

Questions about this account

Who was involved in this account?
The account involves Joseph Smith, Hayden. Each person named here also has a witness page collecting the other accounts involving them.
When did this account take place?
The account is set in the 1830s.
Where did this account take place?
It took place in Not specified.
What kind of miracle is this?
It is filed as a Acts of God / Intervention account reported in United States.
Where does this account come from?
Journal of Discourses, Volume 2 (pages 323-334), discourse 49. The full source citation appears in the Sources section below, with links to the original where available.

Miracle of the Week

One remarkable, documented account in your inbox every Monday, drawn from the full archive.