Death / Near Death / Revival

Aunt Gilbert Returns to Life Five Hours After Ten Men Pronounced Her Dead (1847)

Published October 15, 2026 at 8:18 AM

1840s · 1847
St. Croix Falls, Wisconsin Territory (frontier of Minnesota), USA
Todd Morgan

Contributed by

Todd Morgan

Beaumont, CA, 92223

Share:XFacebookEmail

On September 20, 1847, at the hotel they oversaw in St. Croix Falls, a stranger purporting to be a physician from Quincy, Illinois, sold the Lightner family a root he said would cure colds, bleeding at the lungs, and liver complaint; within moments of tasting it the whole household was violently ill. At three o'clock two of Mary's boys — one ten years and six months old, the other three and a half — were dead. Aunt Gilbert lay lifeless as well, and all three bodies were laid out and covered with a sheet while Mary and her husband were not expected to live from one moment to another. About nine o'clock that evening, Aunt Gilbert came back to life. She suffered convulsions for two weeks afterward, so severe that it took two or three men to hold her. The attending physicians were astonished: they and ten other witnesses had pronounced her dead five full hours before she breathed again. The town, believing the root-seller had deliberately poisoned the family, put a rope around the elderly man's neck and carried him to Mary's window to be hanged — but she, grieving and expecting to join her children in the spirit world, begged them to desist and try him by law. The account stands in her autobiography alongside her testimony that she saw her sons and her aunt in a dream and learned they had accepted the gospel on the other side of the veil.

In Their Own Words

“In the fall of 1847 we moved to St. Croix Falls. We kept a hotel there. One day a man came along, he said he was a doctor from Quincy, Illinois. He had some roots he wanted to sell. He said they were good for colds, bleeding at the lungs, and liver complaint. He gave us some to taste. We all tasted it. In a few minutes we were all taken violently ill. My husband and I were very sick, and my two boys, one ten years and six months old, and the other three and a half years old, were taken with convulsions. They died at three o'clock. Aunt Gilbert was also taken with convulsions and died. We laid them out and covered them with a sheet. My husband and I were not expected to live from one moment to another. About nine o'clock that evening Aunt Gilbert came to life. She had convulsions for two weeks after that, and it took two or three men to hold her. The doctors were surprised at her condition, for they and ten men had pronounced her dead five hours before she came to life again. The people of the town thought the man who sold us the roots had poisoned us on purpose. They put a rope around his neck and took him to my window to hang him. I was feeling very bad, and I expected to die and go to my children, but I begged them not to hang him, but to try him by law. I had a dream that night. I saw my two boys and my aunt. They looked so happy. I asked them if they were happy. They said they were. I asked them if they had accepted the gospel. They said they had. I felt comforted.”

— Mary Elizabeth Rollins Lightner, Autobiography

Sources & References

Autobiography of Mary E. Lightner (1818-1913), The Utah Genealogical and Historical Magazine 17 (July 1926): 193-205, 250, as republished by Book of Mormon Evidence. https://bookofmormonevidence.org/mary-e-rollins-lightners-miracle-stories/ Full first-person account: Utah Genealogical and Historical Magazine, Vol. 17 (1926), pp. 250-251 https://bookofmormonevidence.org/mary-e-rollins-lightners-miracle-stories/

Miracle of the Week

One remarkable, documented account in your inbox every Monday, drawn from the full archive.